Vic Firth American Classic 5A review: the world's best-selling drumstick

The Vic Firth American Classic 5A is a hickory drumstick, SKU 5A, and per Vic Firth's own product page, the world's best-selling stick. 16 inch length, 0.565 inch diameter, medium taper, wood tear-drop tip, lacquer finish. It's the general-purpose default: not specialized for jazz, not specialized for rock, just the size and weight that works across the most musical contexts with the least compromise.

Three things add up to the 5A's decades-long run at the top of stick sales:

1. Diameter sits in the middle of Vic Firth's own lineup. At 0.565 inches, it's thicker than the 7A (0.54 inches, built for light jazz and combo work) and thinner than the 5B (0.595 inches, built for rock, band, and practice where extra durability matters more than finesse). The middle diameter is why the 5A works in more rooms than either neighbor.
2. Medium taper keeps the balance even. Vic Firth's own spec copy says a medium taper gives the best balance between the butt and the tip. No mass concentrated at either end, so the stick doesn't feel back-heavy (a long-taper trait) or front-heavy (a short-taper trait).
3. Volume creates its own advantage. Because the 5A is Vic Firth's highest-selling model, it's stocked everywhere: every drum shop, every big-box music retailer, every gig-adjacent store that carries strings and sticks. A beginner or touring drummer who breaks a stick mid-set can replace a 5A almost anywhere; a niche signature model is a special order.

All three share the same wood, taper, and tip shape; only diameter and length change. Go up to a 5B when you're hitting harder and breaking 5A's regularly. Go down to a 7A when speed and a lighter feel matter more than volume, classic light-jazz territory. Most drummers never need to leave the 5A.

The Black Keys' Patrick Carney named the American Classic 5A directly. Asked what sticks he uses in a 2014 Reddit AMA, he answered:

"I use wood-tip 5A's. And I use a brand called Vic Firth."

That's the honest picture for a stick this universal. Vic Firth's own marketing calls it the world's best-selling stick, so its real user base looks like most working drummers at some point in their career, not one signature face. Several famous drummers play their own named signature stick built around a similar diameter rather than the plain 5A itself. Steve Gadd's Vic Firth SSG sits at 0.550 inches with a barrel wood tip; Charlie Watts's Vic Firth SCW sits at 0.585 inches with an elongated oval tip built for a darker cymbal voice. Both are 5A-family dimensions with their own tweaks, not the plain 5A reviewed here.

If you don't know what stick to buy, or you're replacing a broken pair before a set starts, the Vic Firth American Classic 5A is the safe default. It's not the fastest jazz stick (that's the 7A) and it's not the most durable rock stick (that's the 5B), but it's the one stick that works everywhere without a specific reason to reach for something else. Buy a few pairs. They break, and this is the size you'll replace most often.

Vic Firth

American Classic 5A

Price tier: $

Why this one: Vic Firth's own claim: the world's best-selling stick. Middle-of-the-lineup diameter and a medium taper make it the safest default for players who don't have a specific reason to buy something more specialized.

RockPopJazz

View on AmazonFull review →